Multiple foreign media outlets and the crypto community have quoted experts predicting that China is likely to lift its ban on Bitcoin and cryptocurrency within three months. Previously, China banned cryptocurrencies due to financial risks and environmental concerns, but the ban might be lifted as Hong Kong has approved a Bitcoin ETF. Ben Charoenwong, a scholar at the National University of Singapore, stated that capital flows have exceeded control.
Cryptocurrency media outlet CoinPedia and the well-known crypto community BitcoinLFG reveal that China, known for its strict stance on cryptocurrencies, seems poised to reconsider its Bitcoin ban. This news coincides with Hong Kong taking a significant step in embracing Bitcoin, including the approval of a Bitcoin spot ETF.
Back in September 2017, China began cracking down on cryptocurrencies, implementing strict regulations on Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs), effectively shutting down crypto exchanges. The goal was to reduce financial risks and combat illegal activities related to digital currencies. The ban extended to mining, trading, and ICOs, with environmental concerns over Bitcoin mining playing a role.
In 2021, the crackdown intensified, particularly targeting cryptocurrency mining, leading to the closure of large-scale mining operations nationwide. This campaign prompted many mining enterprises to relocate to jurisdictions with more favorable regulations. Consequently, Bitcoin's hash rate declined significantly, reshaping the global mining landscape.
China's cryptocurrency ban triggered a ripple effect on the industry, causing a decline in Bitcoin's hash rate as miners sought refuge in less regulated jurisdictions. This migration also caused temporary market volatility, affecting Bitcoin's price.
The ban's impact extended beyond China's borders, pushing crypto exchanges and related businesses to relocate to more friendly jurisdictions. This shift altered China's position in the global crypto market.
Recently, Hong Kong's approval of spot Bitcoin and Ether ETFs signals a potential turning point in China's crypto policy. These ETFs have received approval from the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) and began trading on April 30, making Hong Kong the first Asian financial center to embrace cryptocurrencies as mainstream investment tools.
Reports state: "Hong Kong's approval of Bitcoin ETFs has multifaceted implications for China. Although Hong Kong has autonomy in financial matters, its move to become a digital asset hub could prompt mainland China to reconsider its cryptocurrency ban."
With the growing popularity of Hong Kong's Bitcoin ETF, China might see an opportunity to re-engage with the crypto market. The success of these ETFs could showcase the potential of regulated and compliant cryptocurrency investment, addressing China's concerns about financial stability and illegal activities.
Moreover, the success of U.S. Bitcoin spot ETFs has attracted substantial net capital inflows, possibly influencing China's decision to lift the Bitcoin ban.
Although China has banned cryptocurrency trading and mining since 2021, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are more attractive during uncertain economic times. In some cases, they might even become a means of wealth transfer.
Ben Charoenwong from the National University of Singapore pointed out that in May 2021, China completely banned all crypto trading and mining, shocking the crypto world. This move caused Bitcoin to plummet over 30% in one day. The ban involved more than a dozen institutions, from the central bank to various securities and foreign exchange regulators.
According to the People's Bank of China, the official reason at the time was "protecting the safety of people's property and maintaining economic, financial, and social order." However, three years later, Chinese retail investors still seem to be seeking loopholes in the ban.
"Bitcoin's decentralized nature makes it extremely challenging to regulate transactions and allow anyone to participate in the network," Ben explained.
Amid the recent surge in illegal cryptocurrency activity, rising economic uncertainty, and a lackluster Chinese stock market, traditional investment options are losing appeal. With a cumulative decline of over 40% in the Chinese stock market over three consecutive years, retail traders seem inclined to take risks and violate regulations for better returns.
The outlook doesn't seem particularly optimistic either. Local governments face pressure to raise offshore financing through dim sum bonds (bonds denominated in renminbi issued outside China), while banks are forced to raise costly external financing by issuing total loss-absorbing capacity bonds to meet international banking standards. Despite the easing of domestic capital controls, foreign direct investment remains at a historic low. Recent weak economic reports could further worsen already unstable sentiment.
In turbulent times, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies become more attractive. Like gold, Bitcoin can be a hedge against broader economic uncertainty for Chinese investors. Additionally, Bitcoin's decentralized nature makes it challenging to regulate transactions and allows anyone to participate in the network.
Despite the risk of regulatory crackdowns, the potential benefits of alternative investment sources and moving funds abroad while bypassing capital controls have led many retail traders to consider this a worthwhile bet.
Ben continues, "In other words, defying the rules through Bitcoin investment not only offers higher returns but also the potential to bypass capital controls. After all, if using cryptocurrency is already illegal, why not use it for wealth transfer too?"
For this purpose, Chinese cryptocurrency enthusiasts are turning to virtual private networks (VPNs) and offshore crypto exchanges to circumvent the ban. These digital backdoors provide crypto traders with a lifeline, allowing them to operate beyond the scrutiny of Chinese regulators. Additionally, peer-to-peer (P2P) trading and over-the-counter desks are becoming increasingly popular.
"Anyone can anonymously participate in the system, making it difficult to enforce the ban," Ben mentioned.
As the Chinese government tightens restrictions on domestic capital outflows, the marginal benefits of using cryptocurrencies for cross-border transactions increase, making them more attractive to investors. Therefore, the Chinese government may take further restrictive measures, continuing a whack-a-mole approach to prevent external capital inflows. As this situation unfolds, the marginal benefits of using cryptocurrencies will increase further.
To curb illegal use of cryptocurrencies, policymakers may adopt stricter penalties or strengthen regulation to raise the cost of violations. However, this approach requires a delicate balancing act. For China, cracking down on fundamental incentives is challenging, as the government must consider citizens' welfare.
Ben explained, "The resilience and creativity of Chinese retail investors demonstrate the enduring appeal of cryptocurrencies."
"The adaptability of retail investors, coupled with the global and decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies, poses a huge challenge for regulators. In a sense, the current use of cryptocurrencies aligns with its creators' vision, even if capital flows exceed government control. Anyone can anonymously participate in the system, making the ban difficult to enforce."
He concluded, "However, the government cannot stand by idly in the face of this new, unstable asset class. A massive cryptocurrency collapse would worsen investor sentiment and could lead to some turmoil as investors believe they have no choice to make up for their losses. As the tug-of-war between regulators and market forces continues, the resilience and creativity of Chinese retail investors illustrate the enduring appeal of cryptocurrencies."
JinseFinance
Huang Bo
Miyuki
Joy
Coinlive 
Finbold
Beincrypto
Cointelegraph